Why Is TransMilenio Still So Special?

tranmi.jpg

TransMilenio started operations in December 2000, and after more than 8 years it is still regarded as the gold standard for Bus Rapid Transit. Cities as diverse as New York, Delhi, Jakarta, Johannesburg, Beijing and Mexico, to name a few, have all drawn inspiration from Bogotá. But still there is no BRT system that matches its performance – at least not yet.

Why is TransMilenio so special? The clues could be in its “rail like” capacity and travel speed – not seen before in bus systems, and its ability to transform traditional bus operations with an interesting public-private partnership model. The most interesting aspect is that it has shown that it was possible to innovate, transform, and improve transport conditions in a very large city with profound transport challenges. It proved that cities can think outside the box, and bring solutions to the people without costing a fortune or taking decades to build. Kudos to Mayor Enrique Peñalosa, who started it from scratch, and the following administrations, which have continued and expanded it.

After 8 years, 76% of users rate the system as being good or very good. While TransMilenio is still far from solving all the mobility problems in Bogota, it has been a turning point that reversed a downward trend of traffic congestion and urban chaos. TransMilenio’s implementation, along with Bogota’s other sustainable transport initiatives, has resulted in a reduction of private automobile use and increase in non motorized transport in the city, while keeping the transit use stable with a 60%+ share (traditional public transport plus TransMilenio). These trends are quite different than similar ones in other developing cities where auto use increases and transit use declines.

For those interested in facts and figures, you can find this information after the jump.

The system’s infrastructure includes 84 km exclusive busways on central lanes of major arterial roads, roads for feeder buses, 7 terminals, 7 intermediate integration points, and 100 enclosed stations with pre-payment and level boarding to the buses. Trunk lines are served by 1,071 articulated buses, while integrated feeder lines are served by 412 conventional buses (www.transmilenio.gov.co). To maximize capacity, trunk lines accommodate express services stopping at selected stations only, as well as local services stopping at all stations. The high end features of the system and the combination of local and express buses allow the system to carry up to 45,000 passengers per hour per direction at a commercial speed of 29 km/hour.

Bus and Fare Collection services are operated by private operators, including traditional transport providers, procured under competitively tendered concession contracts. Overall system planning, management and oversight is performed by a new public agency (TRANSMILENIO S.A.).

Service in the initial 14 km commenced in December 2000, after less than three years of project planning. Gradual expansion continued over the following 7 years. Currently the system is providing fast, reliable transit to 1,4 million passengers/weekday with a flat fare of COP 1,500 (USD 0,75) per trip. Travel times have been reduced by 32% for system users and traffic fatalities by 88%. Green House Gas reductions have been estimated in 134,011 Tons/year (in 2007, see J. Grütter, CAF, TRANSMILENIO http://cdm.unfccc.int). TransMilenio has had a positive impact on air quality in the vicinity of the BRT corridors. For example, before and after measurements in Av. Caracas show 43% reduction in Sulphur Dioxide, an 18% reduction in Nitrogen Dioxide, and a 12% in particulate matter.

  • jbennett

    Great post. Having spend a little time in Bogata this spring, I’d have to argue that the TransMilenio was able to take advantage of the morphology of the city . . . Bogata is a crazy, hectic, crowded place, but its more LA then New York – spreading out far across la Sabana. A big part of the TransMilenio is about reducing capacity on very large streets – giving the system the room it needs to move quickly and efficiently. Look at the video – it takes up four lanes of roadway, plus more at the stations!

    I visited Mexico City and took the BRT between La Reforma to UNAM via Insurgentes Sur, and was amazed at how, despite the dedicated lanes and metro-style ticket stations, the ride still took forever – mostly because we were city in traffic. It was just too built up to install a BRT system that could circumvent the rest of the city’s traffic problems. I think the real success of trying to establish the TransMilenio elsewhere is going to be in places like Dallas, Los Angeles and Kansas City.

  • http://apocalipsemotorizado.net/2008/08/11/por-ai/ Por aí « apocalipse motorizado

    [...] Um vídeo sobre mobilidade urbana em Portland e um artigo com vídeo sobre o Transmilênio de Bogotá (em inglês). [...]

  • Johan Stroman

    It is great to profile such a successful system and hats off to Penalosa for spearheading the fast-track growth of such a powerful world model. In toasting Bogota’s success story, let us not forget that this system was modelled off of Curitiba’s BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) system and that City and it’s Mayor Jaime Lerner deserves recognition for seeding the idea. As the saying goes, Penalosa was able to see further because he stood on the shoulders of a giant ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standing_on_the_shoulders_of_giants ). That said, I do hope that cities like Bogota, Curitiba and those whom have modelled their systems from theirs, take note of the huge steps not only possible but also well in reach.

  • http://dc.thecityfix.com/is-there-evidence-against-brt-sparking-development/ Is There Evidence Against BRT Sparking Development? | TheCityFix DC

    [...] get so upset with arguments for BRT point me to any resources showing that high-investment BRT—Bogota, not Houston—with physically separated right-of-ways and permanent-seeming stations and the rest, [...]

  • http://adan-ova.blogspot.com Adan Ova

    If people still rate Transmilenio service as “good” or “very good” is because they have no sense of dignity, no respect for themselves and no clue about what their rights are.

    Transmilenio is the worst thing that have happened to my city. it just ruined it. We could have had a subway and we had the money and moreover: it would have been ours (yes, because TM is not ours, we fix the streets for them while they take our money to who knows where). So we have to ask the former mayor why.

  • http://thecityfix.com/transit-enlightened-cities-showcase-brts-brilliance/ “Transit-Enlightened Cities” Showcase BRT’s Brilliance | thecityfix.com

    [...] that most people still associate exclusively with subways. (Sullivan mentions cities like Bogotá, Cleveland, Jakarta, and Guangzhou among the transit-enlightened, but leaves out Curitiba, [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/transit-enlightened-cities-showcase-brts-brilliance/ “Transit-Enlightened Cities” Showcase BRT’s Brilliance | TheCityFix.com

    [...] that most people still associate exclusively with subways. (Sullivan mentions cities like Bogotá, Cleveland, Jakarta, and Guangzhou among the transit-enlightened, but leaves out Curitiba, [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/unep-brt-key-to-sustainable-urban-development-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean/ UNEP: BRT Key to Sustainable Urban Development in Latin America and the Caribbean | thecityfix.com

    [...] how to deal with transportation emissions, the report places the spotlight on the successes of TransMilenio, Bogotá’s bus rapid transit (BRT) system launched in December [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/unep-brt-key-to-sustainable-urban-development-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean/ UNEP: BRT Key to Sustainable Urban Development in Latin America and the Caribbean | TheCityFix.com

    [...] how to deal with transportation emissions, the report places the spotlight on the successes of TransMilenio, Bogotá’s bus rapid transit (BRT) system launched in December [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/transport-and-inequality-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean/ Transport and Inequality in Latin America and the Caribbean | thecityfix.com

    [...] all, linking cities through fast and affordable bus systems like Bogotá’s TransMilenio certainly makes them more connected and cohesive, while providing poorer residents with improved [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/transport-and-inequality-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean/ Transport and Inequality in Latin America and the Caribbean | TheCityFix.com

    [...] all, linking cities through fast and affordable bus systems like Bogotá’s TransMilenio certainly makes them more connected and cohesive, while providing poorer residents with improved [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/access-for-all-transport-for-the-disabled-poor/ Access for All: Transport for the Disabled Poor | thecityfix.com

    [...] to recent work (PDF) by Julie and Peter Roberts, Transmilenio in Bogota, Colombia and similar BRT systems around the world serve as a source of inspiration by showing how [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/access-for-all-transport-for-the-disabled-poor/ Access for All: Transport for the Disabled Poor | TheCityFix.com

    [...] to recent work (PDF) by Julie and Peter Roberts, Transmilenio in Bogota, Colombia and similar BRT systems around the world serve as a source of inspiration by showing how [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/will-los-angeles-revolutionize-u-s-urban-transit-funding/ Will Los Angeles Revolutionize U.S. Urban Transit Funding? | thecityfix.com

    [...] always crucial players in the most promising transit improvements in cities around the world. From TransMilenio in Bogota, Colombia to a new high-tech bus system from an innovative public-private partnership [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/will-los-angeles-revolutionize-u-s-urban-transit-funding/ Will Los Angeles Revolutionize U.S. Urban Transit Funding? | TheCityFix.com

    [...] always crucial players in the most promising transit improvements in cities around the world. From TransMilenio in Bogota, Colombia to a new high-tech bus system from an innovative public-private partnership [...]

  • http://gondolaproject.com/2010/08/15/sunday-morning-statshot-9/ Sunday Morning Statshot « The Gondola Project

    [...] Number of blogs in the world: over 200,000,000 Percent of blogs posting/tweet daily: 54% bloggers Length exclusive busways in Bogota’s BRT: 84km Number of enclosed stations: 100 Average speed: 29km/hr PPHPD: 45000 [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/the-future-of-sustainable-urban-mobility-integrate-integrate-integrate/ The Future of Sustainable Urban Mobility: Integrate, Integrate, Integrate | thecityfix.com

    [...] The system has improved street safety and reduced accidents by 81 percent. Ultimately mass transit has improved quality of life in Bogota and enhanced the attractiveness of the city in ways far broader than mobility. For more on TransMilenio, go here. [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/the-future-of-sustainable-urban-mobility-integrate-integrate-integrate/ The Future of Sustainable Urban Mobility: Integrate, Integrate, Integrate | TheCityFix.com

    [...] The system has improved street safety and reduced accidents by 81 percent. Ultimately mass transit has improved quality of life in Bogota and enhanced the attractiveness of the city in ways far broader than mobility. For more on TransMilenio, go here. [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/transmilenio-ten-years-down-the-line/ TransMilenio: Ten Years Down the Line | thecityfix.com

    [...] Why is Transmilenio Still So Special? (August 2008) The clues could be in its “rail like” capacity and travel speed – not seen before in bus systems, and its ability to transform traditional bus operations with an interesting public-private partnership model. The most interesting aspect is that it has shown that it was possible to innovate, transform, and improve transport conditions in a very large city with profound transport challenges. [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/transmilenio-ten-years-down-the-line/ TransMilenio: Ten Years Down the Line | TheCityFix.com

    [...] Why is Transmilenio Still So Special? (August 2008) The clues could be in its “rail like” capacity and travel speed – not seen before in bus systems, and its ability to transform traditional bus operations with an interesting public-private partnership model. The most interesting aspect is that it has shown that it was possible to innovate, transform, and improve transport conditions in a very large city with profound transport challenges. [...]

  • http://www.skyscraperlife.com/latin-bar/55471-transmilenio-el-papa-de-los-brt-de-latinoamerica.html#post2828782 Transmilenio el papa de los brt de latinoamerica

    [...] YAKARTA INDONESIA ESTAMBULTURQUIAMADRIDBARCELONA RECONOCIMIENTO INTERNACIONAL DE TRANSMILENIO: Why Is TransMilenio Still So Special? | thecityfix.com APLICACION DE TRANSMILENIO DE BOGOTA EN ESTADOS UNIDOS: [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/urban-development-leaders-lead-but-people-do-the-planning/ Urban Development: Leaders Lead, But People Do the Planning | TheCityFix.com

    [...] a long-term vision for urban improvement. Bogotá’s successful implementation of its BRT system, TransMilenio, can serve as an example. As EMBARQ Senior Transport Engineer Dario Hidalgo points out, Mayor [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/blog/photo-essay-a-tale-of-two-bus-systems-in-bogota/ Photo Essay: A Tale of Two Bus Systems in Bogotá | TheCityFix

    [...] pioneering TransMilenio BRT system carries 1.6 million passengers every weekday. Its many successes, such as reducing pollution, improving safety and reducing travel time for Bogotanos, may be [...]

  • http://urbdp598.wordpress.com/2012/01/15/transmilenio-lessons-for-north-american-cities/ TransMilenio Lessons for North American Cities | urbdp598

    [...] How can North American cities learn from the lessons of Bogotá? Bogotá’s TransMilenio and Why Is the TransMilenio Still So Special? provide information on its positive impact to public transit [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/blog/living-without-a-car-in-bogota-day-12/ Living Without a Car in Bogotá: Day 12 | TheCityFix

    [...] Colombia, home of TransMilenio and Ciclovia, celebrated the 13th annual “Car-Free Day,” proving that life is possible without [...]

  • http://thecityfixbrasil.com/2012/02/08/12%c2%ba-dia-sem-carro-em-bogota/ 12º Dia Sem Carro em Bogotá | TheCityFix Brasil

    [...] (Colômbia), a cidade do TransMilenio e do Domingo das Ciclovias, passou novamente pela conhecida celebração anual para provar que a [...]

  • http://thecityfix.com/blog/urgent-action-required-improve-transmilenio-service/ Urgent Action Required: Improve TransMilenio Service | TheCityFix

    [...] education and the promotion of the positive aspects of the system (we’ve written before about why TransMilenio is still so special.) User participation is also important in suggesting and monitoring improvements. It is also [...]